As we roll into the third calendar year of the pandemic, the debate about how journalists present data on the coronavirus continues to rage. Just six days into 2022, a spiral chart divided the data journalism community into two camps. Our weekly NodeXL curation of the most popular data journalism stories on Twitter highlights a fierce debate about a chart depicting COVID-19 rates over time in a New York Times opinion piece. This edition also features a Times investigation into the prenatal testing industry, a visualization by Reuters of death threats received by election staff, a dynamic river flow tracker by dataviz developer Sam Learner, and Texty.org.ua’s interactive map of the Russian military build-up on Ukraine’s border.
Prenatal Test Failings
The New York Times examined the prenatal testing industry in the United States and found that many of the new, expanded tests on the market that screen for rare chromosomal abnormalities can be strikingly inaccurate. The journalists interviewed researchers and analyzed data from multiple studies to determine how well the five most common prenatal tests performed. Their findings showed that the tests gave false positives about 85% of the time. Investigative journalist Sarah Kliff talks about the investigation in this podcast.
Prenatal tests promise to detect rare genetic diseases in babies by scanning DNA.
Labs market them as "reliable." They tell women to have "total confidence" in results.
It turns out, the grave predictions made by those tests are usually wrong. (1/5)https://t.co/IsskNpYTWg
— Sarah Kliff (@sarahkliff) January 1, 2022
Analyzing Death Threats
Reuters analyzed and visualized more than 850 death threats and hostile messages targeted at election officials during the 2020 US presidential race. The team categorized the messages — “virtually all” of which came from supporters of former President Donald Trump — into several types (racist, “wish death on the recipient,” accuse staff of treason, and more) and determined which were “true threats” and which were “protected speech” under the US First Amendment. The threats were obtained through public records requests, interviews, and an examination of hundreds of online posts.
Anatomy of a death threat: A visualization from @ReutersGraphics breaks down the surge of death threats against U.S. election officials by Trump supporters who believe his false claims about 2020 voting fraud https://t.co/qrdBMGpc7I
— Reuters (@Reuters) December 30, 2021
Where Do Raindrops Go?
Data visualization developer Sam Learner created an interactive river flow tool, which depicts the likely journey of a single raindrop in any part of the world flowing down streams and rivers to its final destination. Find the code and more details behind the project’s data here, and use the site to check out the trajectory of the Seine in France, the Amazon in Brazil, or the Nile through northern Africa.
— Lisa Abend (@LisaAbend) January 5, 2022
Tracking the Wildebeest
The changing climate and seasonal rains at the Serengeti National Park in north-central Tanzania spur more than a million wildebeests to travel up to 1,750 miles (2,800 kilometers) annually across the plains in search of food and water. National Geographic used data from GPS trackers fitted on six wildebeests to visualize their migration routes. Want to follow the movements of the wildebeests and other animals? Check out the Serengeti Tracker project, led by scientists at Scotland’s Glasgow University.
What a visualization and presentation 🤯https://t.co/bgiCtu221s
— Disyacitta Awanda (@disyaawanda) December 1, 2021
A spiral graph featured in a New York Times 0pinion piece became a hotly debated topic among the data journalism community. The graph, which depicts the number of COVID-19 cases over time in the United States, has both supporters and critics. Some took the initiative to rework the visualization to convey the information more clearly, including Github’s research engineer Amelia Wattenberger and Sourya Shrestha, an infectious disease modeler at Johns Hopkins School of Public Health. Statistician Nathan Yau offered up a helpful tutorial to make your own spiral chart. Not sure what the fuss is about? Catch up on the furor with two summaries written by data analyst Nicole Lillian Mark and data professional Neil Richards.
Charts have different purposes.
Maybe the first priority isn't always about comparisons or speed to understanding.
For me the spiral feels like a visual metaphor of a pandemic that feels like it will never end.
— Amanda Makulec MPH (@abmakulec) January 7, 2022
The List of 2021’s Best Visualization Lists
Many media organizations round up their favorite graphics and charts into a year-end best-of list. And for seven years running, data journalist Maarten Lambrechts has compiled them into an annual mega-list, which serves as a handy reference for the entire data journalism community. (His latest edition for 2021 includes GIJN’s own picks of the year’s top 10 data journalism projects.)
— Maarten Lambrechts (@maartenzam) December 30, 2021
Tracking Russia’s Military Build-Up
For weeks, Russia has steadily massed armed forces near its border with Ukraine, prompting concern that the Kremlin may be planning an invasion. Texty.org.ua, an online site in Ukraine (and GIJN member) is using satellite imagery to monitor the situation and estimate the amount of Russian military equipment near the Ukrainian border and in the “temporarily occupied territories” of Crimea and Sevastopol. The interactive database is regularly updated.
Today we published first iteration of our web app to help journalists/analysts/experts in monitoring of RU military bases near Ukraine's border and on occupied territory. This is an interactive map with time series of SAR images from Sentinel-1 satelliteshttps://t.co/x0aCmIRuGR
— Anatoliy Bondarenko (@dvrnd) January 4, 2022
How Fast Do Germans Drive?
In German city centers, many people drive faster than the speed limit. This is according to a Der Spiegel analysis of data covering 40 German cities from the TomTom navigation provider. Traffic analysts attribute speeding to poor road design, low fines, and a lack of government control. You can explore the profiles of German metropolises, and how drivers speed through them, street-by-street in this interactive piece.
With a speed limit of 50 km/h, Germans drive 60.
My colleague @hdambeck analyzed traffic data for 40 cities. I contributed an interactive map, where readers can explore patterns in detail (road segment level, day/night, different thresholds)https://t.co/sca5BF0jj7 (€)#ddj pic.twitter.com/BQUXueyCNk
— Patrick Stotz (@PatrickStotz) January 8, 2022
Europe prides itself on championing freedom of movement, but countries across the region are increasingly fortifying borders and building barriers. The UK’s Telegraph published a long-form scroll story documenting the walls built and how high-tech security (for example cameras, sound cannons, and heat sensors) has been deployed along the borders to keep migrants out. Using data from public records, government information, and news reports, the Telegraph reports that there are now 1,800 kilometers (approx. 1,100 miles) of walls and fences either built or under construction on Europe’s borders. That’s nearly as long as 12 Berlin Walls.
Fortress Europe: How 1,800km of walls and fences are keeping desperate migrants out https://t.co/Bd0KEsCRrL
— Ides MF Debruyne (@IdesDebruyne) January 5, 2022
As part of the Earth Journalism Network’s 2021 Mekong Data Journalism Fellowship, 30 journalists from Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam accessed and analyzed public data sets related to the Mekong River Basin in Asia on renewable energy, dams, fish catches, mangrove forests, erosion, and more. As a result, reporters in the group have produced a series of data-driven stories revealing the water security challenges and solutions in the region.
From May-Dec 2021, 30 journalists from the 5 Mekong countries trained as data journos to dive into the complexities of the Mekong River Basin. We're excited to share their stories & resources for interested journos! #ddj @StimsonCenter @EastWestCenter https://t.co/4nlUZ8fZdf pic.twitter.com/wZur6p9bI1
— Earth Journalism Network (@earthjournalism) December 28, 2021
Eunice Au is GIJN’s program manager. Previously, she was a Malaysia correspondent for Singapore’s The Straits Times, and a journalist at the New Straits Times. She has also written for The Sun, Malaysian Today, and Madam Chair.