Investigating Sexual Abuse: Reporting Tips and Tools

Image: Shamia Casiano / Pexels

The subject of sexual violence remains a sensitive if not taboo subject in much of the world and often goes unreported. Watchdog journalism has started digging deeper into sexual violence, but these investigations are still few relative to the estimated number of cases worldwide.

This guide is based on tips and techniques drawn from a November 2020 GIJN webinar, Investigating Sexual Abuse, and augmented by a GIJN Resource Center search of relevant case studies, useful organizations, and guides. The webinar featured speakers Lénaïg Bredoux, gender editor at Mediapart; Sophia Huang, a freelance journalist in China; Ashwaq Masoodi, a freelance journalist in India; and moderator Susanne Reber, executive producer of podcasts at Scripps, a US media company.

 

Case Studies

Useful Organizations and Guides

Tips for Reporting

Case Studies

Here is a selection of recent stories about investigations into sexual abuse or violence.

The French Journalists Behind Trail-Blazing Investigations into Sexual Violence (2020). GIJN’s French Editor Marthe Rubio talks with Lénaïg Bredoux and Marine Turchi about the methodologies and motivations behind the French investigative website Mediapart’s investigations into sexual violence.

The Impact of #MeToo in France: An Interview with Lénaïg Bredoux (2019). Bredoux discusses her work covering sexual misconduct allegations, and having to defend it in court, with Aida Alami for the New York Review of Books.

Image: Screenshot

Verified (2020). This 10-episode investigative reporting podcast from the Investigative Reporting Network Italy (IRPI) and US company Stitcher tells the story of a sexual predator who drugged and assaulted women vacationing in Italy. RivistaStudio reviews the podcast in Lo Stupratore su Couchsurfing.

A #MeToo Awakening Stirs in Iran (2020). Accusations of sexual misconduct over a 30-year span against Iranian artist Aydin Aghdashloo.

Rodney Edwards: How One Brave Man Walked into our Newspaper Office to Uncover Shocking Abuse Cases (2019). Edwards writes about how he and child abuse victims exposed wrongdoing in their award-winning probe.

New York Times & New Yorker Series on Weinstein and Others: (2018). The Pulitzer Prize in Public Service was shared by the New York Times for reporting led by Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey, and The New Yorker, for reporting by Ronan Farrow, for journalism that exposed powerful and wealthy sexual predators.

‘She Said’ Recounts How Two Times Reporters Broke the Harvey Weinstein Story (2019).

Advice for Reporters Working with Survivors of Child Abuse (2019). Tips from journalists at GIJC19 on how to carry out sensitive investigations into abuse.

The Pathology of a Predator (2019). This four-part series from Australia’s online site Crikey reports on pedophiles in the Catholic Church through interviews with priests, brothers, seminarians, and victims. Suzanne Smith went on to write The Altar Boys, a history of clerical pedophilia, published in 2020.

Investigative Journalists Propel #MeToo Reporting at China’s Universities (2018). Three cases at China’s top universities on the front lines of #MeToo reporting in China, from GIJN’s Ying Chan, Siran Liang, and Lizzy Huang.

How #MeToo China Inspired a User-Generated Model of Investigative Journalism (2018). The second in a series on the wave of investigative reporting behind the #MeToo movement in China, by Ying Chan for GIJN.

Belatedly, The Indianapolis Star Gets Its Due for Gymnastics Investigation (2018). This piece explores the two year investigative project that led to the arrest of the former doctor of the US national gymnastics team, who was accused of molesting more than 100 girls, including Olympic athletes.

What Happens When #MeToo Goes to Court (2018). Ashwaq Masoodi writes about the years-long road to justice in India for victims of sexual harassment.

Politiken’s investigation of abuse of child actors in Danish film industry (2018).

Covering Sexual Assault: Reporting on rape and sexual assault challenges journalists to build trust with sources and avoid injecting bias into the story (2017). In NiemanReports, Michael Blanding wrote about the importance of covering sexual assault, and how to do it well.

No #MeToo in China? Female Journalists Face Sexual Harassment, but Remain Silent (2017). A profile of Chinese journalist Sophia Huang Xueqin and the problems of sexual harassment and abuse in China.

Rolling Stone’s Investigation: ‘A Failure that was Avoidable’ (2015). The Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism’s investigation into a story of rape on campus that had to be retracted, due to failures encompassing reporting, editing, editorial supervision and fact-checking.

Bangladesh: Protests Erupt Over Rape Case (2020). According to Human Rights Watch, attackers in Bangladesh are rarely held to account, with a conviction rate for rape below 1%. Women often tell the media they do not feel comfortable going to the police.

Sexual Violence: Uganda Police Should Support Victims, Not Blame Them (2020). Human Rights Watch.

Finding the Courage to Cover Sexual Violence (2014). Frank Smyth of the Committee to Protect Journalists reviews the strategies and repercussions around covering sexual assault.

Investigating Rape: An Examination of How the Police and Prosecutors Approach Rape Allegations (2014). The Bureau of Investigative Journalism investigation includes case studies and reports from independent panels.

Catholic Church Abuses (2003). The Boston Globe won the Pulitzer Prize for Public Service for its comprehensive coverage of sexual abuse by priests in the Roman Catholic Church (dramatized in the movie Spotlight). The Dart Center interviews the Spotlight team in 2016 to talk about how they did it, and here’s GIJN’s David E. Kaplan on Eight Lessons on Investigative Reporting from “Spotlight.”

Useful Organizations and Guides

Image: Ra Dragon / Unsplash

The Dart Center for Journalism & Trauma: Reporting on Sexual Violence has many resources for covering sexual violence, including quick coverage tips (also in Arabic), and how to maintain boundaries with sources and colleagues.

The Fundación Gabo translated this Dart Center tipsheet to covering rape cases into Spanish.

IJnet Español translated into Spanish the Dart Center’s Tips for Journalists Covering Sexual Abuse Cases.

The UK’s Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO) sets out the law and gives guidance to reporters investigating sexual offenses.

Angles, a UK-based organization whose goals are to increase understanding of sexual and domestic abuse and violence, offers resources, statistics, reporting guidelines, and useful contacts for journalists.

The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights. Woven out of the African Union, this commission, set up to tackle human rights issues, has a sexual violence component. Here’s the commission’s guide to combating sexual violence and its consequences across Africa.

Africa’s Institute of Security Studies publishes resources for the continent, including items like this policy brief on sexual violence in South Africa.

Safe Spaces strives to be South Africa’s key knowledge hub for resources, good practices, and events on a wide spectrum of topics related to community safety as well as violence and crime prevention, including sexual violence.

OCHA ReliefWeb produced this Handbook for Journalists, Reporting on Violence Against Women and Girls.

Sexual Violence Research Initiative (SVRI) is a global network on research on violence against women and children.

National Sexual Violence Resource Center (NSVRC) is a US-based nonprofit that works with the media to promote informed reporting on sexual violence.

The US-based Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN) is the nation’s largest anti-sexual violence organization. It produced these Tips for Interviewing Survivors for journalists and a glossary of key terms and phrases.

The Investigation and Prosecution of Sexual Violence, from the Human Rights Center at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Law, lays out the difficulties that arise in the investigation of sexual violence.

Reporting on Rape & Sexual Violence: A Media Toolkit to Better Media Coverage from the Chicago Taskforce on Violence Against Girls & Young Women, includes examples of good and bad reporting on sexual violence, along with tips and notes on understanding statistics.

These handbooks are written for local US reporters, but they both provide a good guide on questions to ask and processes to follow: Reporting Sexual Assault: A Guide for Journalists from the Michigan Coalition to End Domestic & Sexual Violence and the Minnesota Coalition Against Sexual Assault’s Reporting on Sexual Violence: A Guide for Journalists.

Tips for Reporting

Research Laws and Statistics

Research local conditions and understand the cultural environment.

  • Gather statistics for your region; find data on prevalence of sexual violence.
  • Be aware that statistics indicate that most victims do not report sexual assaults to law enforcement.
  • What percentage were reported to police? What percentage were not?
  • How many cases were prosecuted? What percentage resulted in a conviction, or acquittal?
  • Understand relevant laws, regulations, and definitions of common terms.
  • Find experts, groups, or organizations to help make your story more accurate, and to provide different perspectives.
Find Stories

In a session on Investigating Sexual Harassment at the 2019 Global Investigative Journalism Conference, Pascale Mueller from BuzzFeed News Germany listed these ways to find stories:

  • Tips from anonymous sources (via Signal or SecureDrop)
  • Tips from researchers/unionists
  • Tips from the survivors themselves, or witnesses
  • Join social media groups and ask questions
  • Have a public, easily accessible, and secure way for people to contact you
  • Reach out to the community you want to cover
Build Trust

Be clear with survivors about your process, and explain your work every step of the way.

  • Tell them it will be long and difficult, and it is your job to corroborate information.
  • Acknowledge the risk they took to come forward.
  • Explain why it will take time, how you work, and how you collect evidence.
  • Understand that it’s about ongoing consent, and it’s a relationship, not a transaction.
  • Survivors may have been robbed of their agency (power); let them decide how to communicate, where to meet, when to talk and for how long.
  • Marine Turchi notes that there is “a time for listening and a time for fact-checking.”
Compile Evidence

It is not just a question of “he-said, she-said.” There is often tangible evidence that can be compiled. So when you are told there is “no proof,” look for a body of evidence:

  • Survivor’s documents, text messages, emails, social media content, diary, letters, pictures to show who knew each other.
  • Documents from family, friends, colleagues of the victim, and accused.
  • Other victims or witnesses, first person accounts.
  • Victims may have deleted their messages to the perpetrator, but often they would have spoken about it to others.
  • Financial or legal records, like disciplinary records, testimony, lawsuits. These may reveal who else was involved, who else knew.
  • Verify dates and locations to build a timeline.
Recognize Patterns

Sex abuse is about power and domination.

  • Stories are stronger when they involve multiple victims, because that shows a pattern.
  • Multiple witnesses may have spoken with the perpetrator, and can tell whether the person used sexist language or behavior, showing patterns of behavior.
  • Understand imbalances related to gender, social class, hierarchies.
  • Contact institutions accused of complicity, but don’t reveal everything you know or give clues about your sources.
Use Precise Language

Carefully choose words and phrases. Definitions matter. Rape is violence, not “sex.”

  • Let survivors pick words that fit their situations (e.g., “survivor,” “victim”).
  • Avoid asking survivors “why” questions, which may imply they were responsible in some way.
  • Question institutional failures, not the victim. Ask “What prevents you from going to the police?” not “Why didn’t you go to the police?”.
Recognize Your Responsibility

Reporting stories of sexual assault requires a combination of compassion, thick skin, empathy, sensitivity, respect, and psychological awareness. We report the stories when a private issue becomes a public concern.

  • Respect survivors and their right to say no, and to make their own choices.
  • Constantly balance between empathy and facts.
  • After the story is released, keep in touch with the survivor.
  • Upon publication, survivors may find consolation with other survivors or groups.